We've stayed here ourselves and its a big thumbs up from the PROC. You can even rent out the whole place for a weekend in low season with no fussy owners milling around either.

The name might give you the impression that it's up mountain but it's literally only a stone's throw from Baltimore 'city centre' - the pubs and the shop that is! Five minutes walk from the pier where you can catch a ferry to heaven aka Sherkin Island and Cape Clear.